Action Comics #251

Track value, sales history, and listings for this issue.

Action Comics #251
Comic Price Guide by CGC Grade

Sign up free to see estimated worth (fair value), annual growth, last sale, time-based trends, and liquidity for all grades.

Free • No credit card required

Grade Estimated Worth

Action Comics #251
CGC Grade 9.4

Sales data shows unusual volume, with a 750.0% change in year to date sales volume compared to prior years.

Fair Value	Market Value	CAGR
2650	0	3.2%

CAGR (Inflation Adj)	Years Tracked	Correlation
0.6%	17	Strong

1 Year Avg (1 sold)	90 Day Avg (0 sold)	30 Day Avg (0 sold)
2650	0	0

Last Sale (Jul 2025)	Avg Days To Sale	Sales Tracked
2650	3127	3

All Time Low (2008)	All Time High (2016)	Down ATH (%)
1554	2868	7.6%

Issue Volume (% YTD)	Issue Volume (YTD)	Relative Volume (YTD)
750.0%	1	8.5

Action Comics #251
CGC Grade 9.2

⚠️ No sales in 5+ years — estimate based on nearby grades

Fair Value	Market Value	CAGR
1816	0	2.9%

CAGR (Inflation Adj)	Years Tracked	Correlation
0.1%	5	Strong

1 Year Avg (0 sold)	90 Day Avg (0 sold)	30 Day Avg (0 sold)
0	0	0

Last Sale (Nov 2011)	Avg Days To Sale	Sales Tracked
555	1886	2

All Time Low (2006)	All Time High (2011)	Down ATH (%)
480	555	0.0%

Issue Volume (% YTD)	Issue Volume (YTD)	Relative Volume (YTD)
NA	0	0.0

Action Comics #251
CGC Grade 8.5

⚠️ No sales in 5+ years — estimate based on nearby grades

Fair Value	Market Value	CAGR
982	0	34.5%

CAGR (Inflation Adj)	Years Tracked	Correlation
32.5%	3	Strong

1 Year Avg (0 sold)	90 Day Avg (0 sold)	30 Day Avg (0 sold)
0	0	0

Last Sale (Dec 2016)	Avg Days To Sale	Sales Tracked
416	1280	2

All Time Low (2013)	All Time High (2016)	Down ATH (%)
171	416	0.0%

Issue Volume (% YTD)	Issue Volume (YTD)	Relative Volume (YTD)
NA	0	0.0

Action Comics #251
CGC Grade 7.5

Sales data shows unusual volume, with a 400.0% change in year to date sales volume compared to prior years.

Fair Value	Market Value	CAGR
400	445	0.7%

CAGR (Inflation Adj)	Years Tracked	Correlation
-3.9%	5	None/Very Weak

1 Year Avg (2 sold)	90 Day Avg (0 sold)	30 Day Avg (0 sold)
266	0	0

Last Sale (Sep 2025)	Avg Days To Sale	Sales Tracked
400	630	4

All Time Low (2025)	All Time High (2025)	Down ATH (%)
133	400	0.0%

Issue Volume (% YTD)	Issue Volume (YTD)	Relative Volume (YTD)
400.0%	2	5.0

Comics For Sale

🔄 Updated daily - new comics added every 24 hours!

We may earn a small commission on purchases made through links to eBay.

Listed Price $445

11.3%

Slightly Below Fair Value

eBay

Action Comics #251
CGC Grade 7.0

Fair Value	Market Value	CAGR
264	0	5.1%

CAGR (Inflation Adj)	Years Tracked	Correlation
2.3%	21	Strong

1 Year Avg (0 sold)	90 Day Avg (0 sold)	30 Day Avg (0 sold)
0	0	0

Last Sale (Oct 2024)	Avg Days To Sale	Sales Tracked
264	1938	5

All Time Low (2003)	All Time High (2024)	Down ATH (%)
93	264	0.0%

Issue Volume (% YTD)	Issue Volume (YTD)	Relative Volume (YTD)
NA	0	0.0

Action Comics #251
CGC Grade 5.0

Fair Value	Market Value	CAGR
178	295	0.0%

CAGR (Inflation Adj)	Years Tracked	Correlation
-4.0%	1	None/Very Weak

1 Year Avg (0 sold)	90 Day Avg (0 sold)	30 Day Avg (0 sold)
0	0	0

Last Sale (Aug 2023)	Avg Days To Sale	Sales Tracked
178	NA	1

All Time Low (2023)	All Time High (2023)	Down ATH (%)
178	178	0.0%

Issue Volume (% YTD)	Issue Volume (YTD)	Relative Volume (YTD)
NA	0	0.0

Comics For Sale

🔄 Updated daily - new comics added every 24 hours!

We may earn a small commission on purchases made through links to eBay.

Listed Price $295

NA Fair Value

eBay

Action Comics #251
CGC Grade 4.5

Fair Value	Market Value	CAGR
99	0	0.0%

CAGR (Inflation Adj)	Years Tracked	Correlation
-2.9%	1	None/Very Weak

1 Year Avg (0 sold)	90 Day Avg (0 sold)	30 Day Avg (0 sold)
0	0	0

Last Sale (Nov 2024)	Avg Days To Sale	Sales Tracked
99	NA	1

All Time Low (2024)	All Time High (2024)	Down ATH (%)
99	99	0.0%

Issue Volume (% YTD)	Issue Volume (YTD)	Relative Volume (YTD)
NA	0	0.0

Action Comics #251
CGC Grade 4.0

Fair Value	Market Value	CAGR
67	0	0.0%

CAGR (Inflation Adj)	Years Tracked	Correlation
-4.0%	1	None/Very Weak

1 Year Avg (0 sold)	90 Day Avg (0 sold)	30 Day Avg (0 sold)
0	0	0

Last Sale (Jan 2023)	Avg Days To Sale	Sales Tracked
67	NA	1

All Time Low (2023)	All Time High (2023)	Down ATH (%)
67	67	0.0%

Issue Volume (% YTD)	Issue Volume (YTD)	Relative Volume (YTD)
NA	0	0.0

Action Comics #251
CGC Grade 1.5

No sales have been tracked for this grade.

Fair Value	Market Value	CAGR
-	-	-

CAGR (Inflation Adj)	Years Tracked	Correlation
-	-	-

1 Year Avg ( sold)	90 Day Avg ( sold)	30 Day Avg ( sold)
-	-	-

Last Sale (-)	Avg Days To Sale	Sales Tracked
-	-	0

All Time Low (-)	All Time High (-)	Down ATH (%)
-	-	-

Issue Volume (% YTD)	Issue Volume (YTD)	Relative Volume (YTD)
-	0	-

Action Comics #251
CGC Grade 1.0

No sales have been tracked for this grade.

Fair Value	Market Value	CAGR
-	-	-

CAGR (Inflation Adj)	Years Tracked	Correlation
-	-	-

1 Year Avg ( sold)	90 Day Avg ( sold)	30 Day Avg ( sold)
-	-	-

Last Sale (-)	Avg Days To Sale	Sales Tracked
-	-	0

All Time Low (-)	All Time High (-)	Down ATH (%)
-	-	-

Issue Volume (% YTD)	Issue Volume (YTD)	Relative Volume (YTD)
-	0	-

Action Comics #251
CGC Grade 0.5

No sales have been tracked for this grade.

Fair Value	Market Value	CAGR
-	-	-

CAGR (Inflation Adj)	Years Tracked	Correlation
-	-	-

1 Year Avg ( sold)	90 Day Avg ( sold)	30 Day Avg ( sold)
-	-	-

Last Sale (-)	Avg Days To Sale	Sales Tracked
-	-	0

All Time Low (-)	All Time High (-)	Down ATH (%)
-	-	-

Issue Volume (% YTD)	Issue Volume (YTD)	Relative Volume (YTD)
-	0	-

Quick Insights on Action Comics #251 in 2025

When was the last recorded sale for Action Comics #251?

The last recorded sale was a CGC 7.5 for $400 on 09/01/2025 at eBay.

What was the highest sale recorded for Action Comics #251?

The highest recorded sale was a CGC 9.4 for $2,868 on 08/04/2016 at Heritage Auctions [1].

What was the lowest sale recorded for Action Comics #251?

The lowest recorded sale was a CGC 4.0 for $67 on 01/01/2023 at eBay.

Which grade has the best annual growth for Action Comics #251?

A CGC 7.0 shows the highest inflation-adjusted CAGR at 2.3% over 2003–2024 (21 years).

How often does Action Comics #251 sell?

Average days to sell vary by grade (~every 630–3127 days by grade), ranging from CGC 7.5 every 630 days to CGC 9.4 every 3127 days.

Unleash the Power of Underval

1. Start by searching your favorite comic

Search by title and issue to explore market data, sales history, and real-time pricing trends for each grade.

2. Discover valuable insights

Gain insight into key metrics such as Fair Value, Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR), and time-based average sale prices by issue and grade.

3. Find comics listed below fair value

Quickly find comics like Action Comics #251 priced below fair value across the web through auction sites like eBay, based on recent market data.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Underval?

Underval is a free comic-book analytics and listings platform. We estimate fair value by grade, display annual growth rate, show recent sales and sales history, and surface active listings.

Where do your sales come from?

We aggregate public online sales from major marketplaces and auctions such as eBay and Heritage Auctions, then normalize and de-duplicate them by issue and grade.

How do you calculate “Estimated Worth (Fair Value)?”

Fair value blends recent realized sales with longer-term trends, outlier filtering, and grade-level liquidity. It’s an informational estimate, not an offer.

How often are values updated?

Values update as new sales appear. Each grade’s “Updated on” date reflects the most recent sale we’ve matched for that grade.

Which grades do you cover?

We track Universal CGC-graded copies across common scale points (e.g., 0.5–10). Availability varies by issue and observed market activity.

Do you offer investment advice?

No. Underval provides data and estimates for research purposes only. Always do your own diligence before buying or selling.

12 searches Last searched: 2025-12-17

Price guide FAQ

Fair Value by CGC Grade — Action Comics #251

What is Action Comics #251 CGC 9.4 worth in 2025?

Estimated worth (Fair Value) is $2650 based on 3 sales over ~17 years .
Informational estimate, not an offer. Updated on 07/07/2025 based on the last sale.

What is Action Comics #251 CGC 9.2 worth in 2025?

Estimated worth (Fair Value) is $1816 based on 2 sales over ~5 years .
Informational estimate, not an offer. Updated on 11/30/2011 based on the last sale.

What is Action Comics #251 CGC 8.5 worth in 2025?

Estimated worth (Fair Value) is $982 based on 2 sales over ~3 years .
Informational estimate, not an offer. Updated on 12/12/2016 based on the last sale.

What is Action Comics #251 CGC 7.5 worth in 2025?

Estimated worth (Fair Value) is $400 based on 4 sales over ~5 years .
Informational estimate, not an offer. Updated on 09/01/2025 based on the last sale.

What is Action Comics #251 CGC 7.0 worth in 2025?

Estimated worth (Fair Value) is $264 based on 5 sales over ~21 years .
Informational estimate, not an offer. Updated on 10/22/2024 based on the last sale.

What is Action Comics #251 CGC 6.5 worth in 2025?

Estimated worth (Fair Value) is $104 based on 1 sales over ~1 years .
Informational estimate, not an offer. Updated on 01/14/2024 based on the last sale.

What is Action Comics #251 CGC 5.5 worth in 2025?

Estimated worth (Fair Value) is $103 based on 1 sales over ~1 years .
Informational estimate, not an offer. Updated on 09/08/2024 based on the last sale.

What is Action Comics #251 CGC 5.0 worth in 2025?

Estimated worth (Fair Value) is $178 based on 1 sales over ~1 years .
Informational estimate, not an offer. Updated on 08/31/2023 based on the last sale.

What is Action Comics #251 CGC 4.5 worth in 2025?

Estimated worth (Fair Value) is $99 based on 1 sales over ~1 years .
Informational estimate, not an offer. Updated on 11/05/2024 based on the last sale.

What is Action Comics #251 CGC 4.0 worth in 2025?

Estimated worth (Fair Value) is $67 based on 1 sales over ~1 years .
Informational estimate, not an offer. Updated on 01/01/2023 based on the last sale.

Legal Disclaimer
Underval is a platform designed to provide information about the potential value of comic books based on data analysis. We do not provide investment advice, and any information provided on our platform is for informational purposes only. While we strive to offer accurate and reliable data, the decision to purchase any comic book should be based on your own research and judgment. Underval does not guarantee the accuracy, completeness, or reliability of any information provided, and we shall not be held liable for any actions taken based on the content available on our platform. By using Underval, you acknowledge and agree to these terms.