Storyline
The Joker returns to his darker, more dangerous roots in a landmark Bronze Age story that redefined him as a lethal Batman villain.
The Joker returns to his darker, more dangerous roots in a landmark Bronze Age story that redefined him as a lethal Batman villain.
Not every CGC grade of Batman #251 performs the same. Go beyond price guides and compare historical growth, sales activity, and estimated fair values to evaluate which grades are worth considering.
Explore Full AnalyticsExplore the full analytics for free before creating an account.
Compare every tracked CGC grade for Batman #251 using estimated fair value, historical growth, liquidity, and market activity.
Compare All CGC GradesExplore the full analytics for free before creating an account.
The last recorded sale was a CGC 6.0 for $650 on 11/05/2026 at eBay.
The highest recorded sale was a CGC 9.8 for $39,600 on 11/24/2024 at Heritage Auctions [1].
The lowest recorded sale was a CGC 5.5 for $29 on 01/18/2004 at Heritage Auctions [1].
A CGC 7.5 shows the highest inflation-adjusted growth at 16.7% over 2011–2026 (15 years).
Average days to sell vary by grade (~every 23–374 days by grade), ranging from CGC 6.5 every 23 days to CGC 9.8 every 374 days.
Search Batman #251 and other comics to explore grade-level values, recent sales, and market activity.
Compare fair value, recent sales, growth, liquidity, and long-term performance across the tracked grades for Batman #251.
Find listings for Batman #251 and other comics, then quickly compare asking prices against Underval’s estimated fair values.
Join hundreds of collectors already using Underval.