UNDERVAL

Batman #251

Batman #251 worth by CGC grade ranges from $158 to $26,400 across tracked CGC grades. Compare values, recent sales, and long-term performance across every grade below.
Batman #251 cover

Storyline

The Joker returns to his darker, more dangerous roots in a landmark Bronze Age story that redefined him as a lethal Batman villain.

Batman #251
Value & Price Guide by CGC Grade

Free • Takes 10 seconds • No credit card required
Grade Fair Value

Want to compare every CGC grade?

Create a free Underval account to compare grades, track value changes, and find comics listed below fair value.

Quick Insights on Batman #251 in 2026

When was the last recorded sale for Batman #251?

The last recorded sale was a CGC 7.0 for $700 on 08/14/2026 at eBay.

What was the highest sale recorded for Batman #251?

The highest recorded sale was a CGC 9.8 for $39,600 on 11/24/2024 at Heritage Auctions [1].

What was the lowest sale recorded for Batman #251?

The lowest recorded sale was a CGC 5.5 for $29 on 01/18/2004 at Heritage Auctions [1].

Which grade has the best annual growth for Batman #251?

A CGC 7.5 shows the highest inflation-adjusted growth at 16.5% over 2011–2026 (15 years).

How often does Batman #251 sell?

Average days to sell vary by grade (~every 23–374 days by grade), ranging from CGC 6.5 every 23 days to CGC 9.8 every 374 days.

Use Underval to Research Batman #251

Search for Batman #251 and other comics on Underval

1. Research Batman #251

Search Batman #251 and other comics to explore grade-level values, recent sales, and market activity.
Compare CGC grade metrics for Batman #251

2. Compare CGC Grades

Compare fair value, recent sales, growth, liquidity, and long-term performance across the tracked grades for Batman #251.
Find Batman #251 listings below fair value

3. Find Buying Opportunities

Find listings for Batman #251 and other comics, then quickly compare asking prices against Underval’s estimated fair values.
122 searches Last searched: 2026-08-17
Previous issue Batman #250
Current Batman #251
Next issue Batman #252

Legal Disclaimer
Underval is a platform designed to provide information about the potential value of comic books based on data analysis. We do not provide investment advice, and any information provided on our platform is for informational purposes only. While we strive to offer accurate and reliable data, the decision to purchase any comic book should be based on your own research and judgment. Underval does not guarantee the accuracy, completeness, or reliability of any information provided, and we shall not be held liable for any actions taken based on the content available on our platform. By using Underval, you acknowledge and agree to these terms.