Storyline
Captain America reflects over his many years as America's living legend! Witness the shocking ending to The Mercenary and the Madman! The dream begins now!
Captain America #251
Captain America #251 worth by CGC grade ranges from
$10 to
$199 across tracked CGC grades.
Compare values, recent sales, and long-term performance across every grade below.
Captain America #251
Value & Price Guide by CGC Grade
Free • Takes 10 seconds • No credit card required
Grade
Fair Value
Captain America
#251
CGC Grade 9.8
CGC Grade 9.8
Fair Value
$199
Estimated worth based on historical sales
Annual Growth
Inflation adjusted
10.8%
Price Trend
Historical consistency
Strong
Recent Market Averages
1 Year Avg
0 sold
—
90 Day Avg
0 sold
—
30 Day Avg
0 sold
—
Market Context
Last Sale
Jun 2025
$199
Years Tracked
Historical coverage
12
Days to Sale
Avg between sales
1401
🔒
Unlock full sales history
See verified sales, price movement, and historical market activity for Captain America #251 CGC 9.8.
Sign Up FreeFree • Takes 10 seconds • No credit
card
required
🔒
Unlock comics for sale
See active listings for Captain America #251 CGC 9.8 and compare asking prices against Underval’s fair value estimate.
Sign Up Free
Find listings faster with a free account.
Captain America
#251
CGC Grade 9.6
CGC Grade 9.6
Fair Value
$39
Estimated worth based on historical sales
Annual Growth
Inflation adjusted
-8.3%
Price Trend
Historical consistency
None/Very Weak
Recent Market Averages
1 Year Avg
0 sold
—
90 Day Avg
0 sold
—
30 Day Avg
0 sold
—
Market Context
Last Sale
Aug 2025
$39
Years Tracked
Historical coverage
12
Days to Sale
Avg between sales
622
🔒
Unlock full sales history
See verified sales, price movement, and historical market activity for Captain America #251 CGC 9.6.
Sign Up FreeFree • Takes 10 seconds • No credit
card
required
🔒
Unlock comics for sale
See active listings for Captain America #251 CGC 9.6 and compare asking prices against Underval’s fair value estimate.
Sign Up Free
Find listings faster with a free account.
Captain America
#251
CGC Grade 9.4
CGC Grade 9.4
Fair Value
$89
Estimated worth based on historical sales
Annual Growth
Inflation adjusted
71.8%
Price Trend
Historical consistency
Strong
Recent Market Averages
1 Year Avg
0 sold
—
90 Day Avg
0 sold
—
30 Day Avg
0 sold
—
Market Context
Last Sale
Jan 2021
$89
Years Tracked
Historical coverage
1
Days to Sale
Avg between sales
166
🔒
Unlock full sales history
See verified sales, price movement, and historical market activity for Captain America #251 CGC 9.4.
Sign Up FreeFree • Takes 10 seconds • No credit
card
required
🔒
Unlock comics for sale
See active listings for Captain America #251 CGC 9.4 and compare asking prices against Underval’s fair value estimate.
Sign Up Free
Find listings faster with a free account.
Captain America
#251
CGC Grade 9.2
CGC Grade 9.2
Fair Value
$35
Estimated worth based on historical sales
Annual Growth
Inflation adjusted
0.0%
Price Trend
Historical consistency
None/Very Weak
Recent Market Averages
1 Year Avg
0 sold
—
90 Day Avg
0 sold
—
30 Day Avg
0 sold
—
Market Context
Last Sale
Apr 2021
$35
Years Tracked
Historical coverage
1
Days to Sale
Avg between sales
—
🔒
Unlock full sales history
See verified sales, price movement, and historical market activity for Captain America #251 CGC 9.2.
Sign Up FreeFree • Takes 10 seconds • No credit
card
required
🔒
Unlock comics for sale
See active listings for Captain America #251 CGC 9.2 and compare asking prices against Underval’s fair value estimate.
Sign Up Free
Find listings faster with a free account.
🔒
Unlock Full Details
Track value changes, compare CGC grades, and spot comics below fair
value for Captain America #251 CGC 9.0.
Sign Up
Free
Already a member? Sign
in.
🔒
Unlock Full Details
Track value changes, compare CGC grades, and spot comics below fair
value for Captain America #251 CGC 8.5.
Sign Up
Free
Already a member? Sign
in.
🔒
Unlock Full Details
Track value changes, compare CGC grades, and spot comics below fair
value for Captain America #251 CGC 8.0.
Sign Up
Free
Already a member? Sign
in.
🔒
Unlock Full Details
Track value changes, compare CGC grades, and spot comics below fair
value for Captain America #251 CGC 7.5.
Sign Up
Free
Already a member? Sign
in.
🔒
Unlock Full Details
Track value changes, compare CGC grades, and spot comics below fair
value for Captain America #251 CGC 7.0.
Sign Up
Free
Already a member? Sign
in.
🔒
Unlock Full Details
Track value changes, compare CGC grades, and spot comics below fair
value for Captain America #251 CGC 6.5.
Sign Up
Free
Already a member? Sign
in.
🔒
Unlock Full Details
Track value changes, compare CGC grades, and spot comics below fair
value for Captain America #251 CGC 6.0.
Sign Up
Free
Already a member? Sign
in.
🔒
Unlock Full Details
Track value changes, compare CGC grades, and spot comics below fair
value for Captain America #251 CGC 5.5.
Sign Up
Free
Already a member? Sign
in.
🔒
Unlock Full Details
Track value changes, compare CGC grades, and spot comics below fair
value for Captain America #251 CGC 5.0.
Sign Up
Free
Already a member? Sign
in.
Captain America
#251
CGC Grade 4.5
CGC Grade 4.5
Fair Value
$10
Estimated worth based on historical sales
Annual Growth
Inflation adjusted
0.0%
Price Trend
Historical consistency
None/Very Weak
Recent Market Averages
1 Year Avg
0 sold
—
90 Day Avg
0 sold
—
30 Day Avg
0 sold
—
Market Context
Last Sale
Nov 2021
$10
Years Tracked
Historical coverage
1
Days to Sale
Avg between sales
—
🔒
Unlock full sales history
See verified sales, price movement, and historical market activity for Captain America #251 CGC 4.5.
Sign Up FreeFree • Takes 10 seconds • No credit
card
required
🔒
Unlock comics for sale
See active listings for Captain America #251 CGC 4.5 and compare asking prices against Underval’s fair value estimate.
Sign Up Free
Find listings faster with a free account.
Captain America
#251
CGC Grade 4.0
CGC Grade 4.0
No sales have been tracked for this grade.
Fair Value
—
Estimated worth based on historical sales
Annual Growth
Inflation adjusted
—
Price Trend
Historical consistency
—
Recent Market Averages
1 Year Avg
sold
—
90 Day Avg
sold
—
30 Day Avg
sold
—
Market Context
Last Sale
Date unavailable
—
Years Tracked
Historical coverage
—
Days to Sale
Avg between sales
—
🔒
Unlock full sales history
See verified sales, price movement, and historical market activity for Captain America #251 CGC 4.0.
Sign Up FreeFree • Takes 10 seconds • No credit
card
required
🔒
Unlock comics for sale
See active listings for Captain America #251 CGC 4.0 and compare asking prices against Underval’s fair value estimate.
Sign Up Free
Find listings faster with a free account.
Captain America
#251
CGC Grade 3.5
CGC Grade 3.5
No sales have been tracked for this grade.
Fair Value
—
Estimated worth based on historical sales
Annual Growth
Inflation adjusted
—
Price Trend
Historical consistency
—
Recent Market Averages
1 Year Avg
sold
—
90 Day Avg
sold
—
30 Day Avg
sold
—
Market Context
Last Sale
Date unavailable
—
Years Tracked
Historical coverage
—
Days to Sale
Avg between sales
—
🔒
Unlock full sales history
See verified sales, price movement, and historical market activity for Captain America #251 CGC 3.5.
Sign Up FreeFree • Takes 10 seconds • No credit
card
required
🔒
Unlock comics for sale
See active listings for Captain America #251 CGC 3.5 and compare asking prices against Underval’s fair value estimate.
Sign Up Free
Find listings faster with a free account.
🔒
Unlock Full Details
Track value changes, compare CGC grades, and spot comics below fair
value for Captain America #251 CGC 3.0.
Sign Up
Free
Already a member? Sign
in.
🔒
Unlock Full Details
Track value changes, compare CGC grades, and spot comics below fair
value for Captain America #251 CGC 2.5.
Sign Up
Free
Already a member? Sign
in.
🔒
Unlock Full Details
Track value changes, compare CGC grades, and spot comics below fair
value for Captain America #251 CGC 2.0.
Sign Up
Free
Already a member? Sign
in.
Captain America
#251
CGC Grade 1.8
CGC Grade 1.8
No sales have been tracked for this grade.
Fair Value
—
Estimated worth based on historical sales
Annual Growth
Inflation adjusted
—
Price Trend
Historical consistency
—
Recent Market Averages
1 Year Avg
sold
—
90 Day Avg
sold
—
30 Day Avg
sold
—
Market Context
Last Sale
Date unavailable
—
Years Tracked
Historical coverage
—
Days to Sale
Avg between sales
—
🔒
Unlock full sales history
See verified sales, price movement, and historical market activity for Captain America #251 CGC 1.8.
Sign Up FreeFree • Takes 10 seconds • No credit
card
required
🔒
Unlock comics for sale
See active listings for Captain America #251 CGC 1.8 and compare asking prices against Underval’s fair value estimate.
Sign Up Free
Find listings faster with a free account.
Captain America
#251
CGC Grade 1.5
CGC Grade 1.5
No sales have been tracked for this grade.
Fair Value
—
Estimated worth based on historical sales
Annual Growth
Inflation adjusted
—
Price Trend
Historical consistency
—
Recent Market Averages
1 Year Avg
sold
—
90 Day Avg
sold
—
30 Day Avg
sold
—
Market Context
Last Sale
Date unavailable
—
Years Tracked
Historical coverage
—
Days to Sale
Avg between sales
—
🔒
Unlock full sales history
See verified sales, price movement, and historical market activity for Captain America #251 CGC 1.5.
Sign Up FreeFree • Takes 10 seconds • No credit
card
required
🔒
Unlock comics for sale
See active listings for Captain America #251 CGC 1.5 and compare asking prices against Underval’s fair value estimate.
Sign Up Free
Find listings faster with a free account.
Captain America
#251
CGC Grade 1.0
CGC Grade 1.0
No sales have been tracked for this grade.
Fair Value
—
Estimated worth based on historical sales
Annual Growth
Inflation adjusted
—
Price Trend
Historical consistency
—
Recent Market Averages
1 Year Avg
sold
—
90 Day Avg
sold
—
30 Day Avg
sold
—
Market Context
Last Sale
Date unavailable
—
Years Tracked
Historical coverage
—
Days to Sale
Avg between sales
—
🔒
Unlock full sales history
See verified sales, price movement, and historical market activity for Captain America #251 CGC 1.0.
Sign Up FreeFree • Takes 10 seconds • No credit
card
required
🔒
Unlock comics for sale
See active listings for Captain America #251 CGC 1.0 and compare asking prices against Underval’s fair value estimate.
Sign Up Free
Find listings faster with a free account.
Captain America
#251
CGC Grade 0.5
CGC Grade 0.5
No sales have been tracked for this grade.
Fair Value
—
Estimated worth based on historical sales
Annual Growth
Inflation adjusted
—
Price Trend
Historical consistency
—
Recent Market Averages
1 Year Avg
sold
—
90 Day Avg
sold
—
30 Day Avg
sold
—
Market Context
Last Sale
Date unavailable
—
Years Tracked
Historical coverage
—
Days to Sale
Avg between sales
—
🔒
Unlock full sales history
See verified sales, price movement, and historical market activity for Captain America #251 CGC 0.5.
Sign Up FreeFree • Takes 10 seconds • No credit
card
required
🔒
Unlock comics for sale
See active listings for Captain America #251 CGC 0.5 and compare asking prices against Underval’s fair value estimate.
Sign Up Free
Find listings faster with a free account.
Want to compare every CGC grade?
Create a free Underval account to compare grades, track value changes, and find comics listed below fair value.
Compare Every CGC Grade for FreeQuick Insights on Captain America #251 in 2026
When was the last recorded sale for Captain America #251?
The last recorded sale was a CGC 9.6 for $39 on 08/10/2025 at eBay.
What was the highest sale recorded for Captain America #251?
The highest recorded sale was a CGC 9.8 for $224 on 03/24/2024 at eBay.
What was the lowest sale recorded for Captain America #251?
The lowest recorded sale was a CGC 4.5 for $10 on 11/14/2021 at eBay.
Which grade has the best annual growth for Captain America #251?
A CGC 9.8 shows the highest inflation-adjusted growth at 10.7% over 2013–2025 (12 years).
How often does Captain America #251 sell?
Average days to sell vary by grade (~every 166–1401 days by grade), ranging from CGC 9.4 every 166 days to CGC 9.8 every 1401 days.
Use Underval to Research Captain America #251
Compare CGC grades, understand the market data, and find listings priced below fair value.
1. Research Captain America #251
Search Captain America #251 and other comics to explore grade-level values, recent sales, and market activity.
2. Compare CGC Grades
Compare fair value, recent sales, growth, liquidity, and long-term performance across the tracked grades for Captain America #251.
3. Find Buying Opportunities
Find listings for Captain America #251 and other comics, then quickly compare asking prices against Underval’s estimated fair values.
Track Values & Compare Grades Free
Join hundreds of collectors already using Underval!
0 searches
Last searched: 2026-08-20